Appeals to the Privy Council
Report No. ANT_1765_01

McNelly v Knowler

Woodbridge v Knowler

Guinand v Knowler

Columbier v Knowler

Antigua 

 

Case Name Long

Victor McNelly v Thomas Knowler

Case Name Long

William Woodbridge v Thomas Knowler

Case Name Long

Joseph Guinand and Henry Guinand v Thomas Knowler

Case Name Long

Anthony Columbier v Thomas Knowler

 

Acts of the Privy Council, Colonial Series

view_APC

APC Citation  

v.4 [599] p.715–716 (19 March 1765 – 13 Feb. 1767)

 
PC Register Citation  

George III v.4 (1 Oct. 1764 – 27 Aug. 1766) p.162, 270, 245–246, 270: PC 2/111/162, 270, 245–246, 270

view  

PC Register Citation  

George III v.5 (Aug. 1766 – Jan. 1768) p.132–138, 167–169: PC 2/112/132–138, 167–169

view  

Colonial Courts

Vice Admiralty Court – 15 June 1764

Participants

Columbier, Anthony, merchant, of London, appellant

Dalrymple, General ___, acting collector and naval officer of Dominica

Guinand, Henry, merchant, of London, appellant

Guinand, Joseph, merchant, of London, appellant

John Turcon and Company, British merchants

Knowler, Thomas, commander of HMS Milford, respondent

Love, Thomas, master of the Elizabeth

Lyne, James, master of the Two Sisters

McNelly, Victor, merchant, of Cork, appellant

Partridge, Joseph, acting commander in chief of Dominica

Sargenton, John, British merchant, in Dominica

Talon, Michael

Turcon, John – see John Turcon and Company

Wills, Thomas, commander of the John [sic] and Betsey

Woodbridge, William, merchant, formerly of Guadaloupe, appellant

Vessels

Elizabeth (ship)

Jane and Betsey (snow)

HMS Milford

Two Sisters (ship)

Description

Condemnation.

Disposition

Affirmed without costs.

Notes

In one instance the APC mistranscribes the name of a vessel as John and Betsey. The correct name, given consistently in PC 2, is Jane and Betsey.

The case was first tried in the Vice-Admiralty Court in Antigua; the ship was seized in Dominique, as is reflected on the printed case.

References in Smith, Appeals to the Privy Council from the American Plantations

Table of Cases (McNelly v Knowler; Guinand v Knowler) (extensive discussion)


DOCUMENTATION

Printed Cases

Appellant’s
case

Cases of the appellants (Anthony Colombier v Thomas Knowler; William Woodbridge v Thomas Knowler; Joseph and Henry Guinand v Thomas Knowler; Victor McNelly v Thomas Knowler), with appendices

Counsel

R. Perryn; Al. Forrester

 
Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36220 f.80r–83v (Colombier v Knowler. No date on dorse. No manuscript notes; minor underlining. Includes appendix)

view

Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36220 f.84r–87v (Woodbridge v Knowler. No date on dorse. One manuscript note. Includes appendix)

view

Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36220 f.95r–98v (Guinand v Knowler. No date on dorse. Manuscript notes confined to check mark on first page. Includes appendix)

view

Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36220 f.99r–104v (McNelly v Knowler. No date on dorse of case; manuscript date on dorse of appendix: Dec. 11 1766. Manuscript notes confined to check mark on first page. Includes appendix)

view

Respondent’s
case

Case of the respondent (Anthony Colombier, Victor McNelly, Joseph and Henry Guinand, and William Woodbridge v Thomas Knowler), with manuscript opinion and observations

Counsel

C. Yorke; Fl. Norton

 
Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36220 f.88r–94v (Colombier, McNelly, Guinand, and Woodbridge v Knowler. Printed date on dorse: 8 July 1766. Manuscript notes on dorse: “Atty Genl. Sir F. Norton”; “Hammersley” [sig]. Extensive manuscript notes and underlining throughout. No appendix. Includes manuscript copy of opinion of Thos. Warner Esq. attorney general of Antigua, and manuscript observations (though not here so called))

view

Privy Council Documents in PC 1 at The National Archives at Kew

Not found