Appeals to the Privy Council

Report No. 01_1703_00

Palmes v Winthrop

Connecticut 

Case Name Short

Palmes v Winthrop

Case Name Long

Edward Palmes v Fitzjohn Winthrop, Richard Christopher and Samuel Fosdick

 

Acts of the Privy Council, Colonial Series

view_APC

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 17 December 1703 – entry 1

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.1 (8 March 1702 – 18 January 1704) p.476: PC 2/79/476

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 3 January 1704 – entry 2

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.1 (8 March 1702 – 18 January 1704) p.489: PC 2/79/489

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 7 January 1704 – entry 3

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.1 (8 March 1702 – 18 January 1704) p.496–497: PC 2/79/496–497

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 10 January 1706 – entry 4

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.68–69: PC 2/81/68–69

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 16 January 1706 – entry 5

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.71–72: PC 2/81/71–72

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453 – 14 February 1706 – entry 6

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.109: PC 2/81/109

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.453–454 – 20 February 1706 – entry 7

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.111, 114–115: PC 2/81/111, 114–115

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.454 – 8 April 1706 – entry 8

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.170: PC 2/81/170

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.454 – 11 April 1706 – entry 9

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.174–175: PC 2/81/174–175

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.454 – 13 March 1707 – entry 10

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.315: PC 2/81/315

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.454 – 25 April 1707 – entry 11

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.350: PC 2/81/350

view  

APC Citation 

v.2 [913] p.454 – 29 April 1707 – entry 12

 
PC Register Citation 

Anne v.3 (11 October 1705 – 29 February 1708) p.354–355: PC 2/81/354–355

view  

Colonial Courts

Court of Assistants – October 1699

Court of Assistants – May 1700

Participants

Christopher, Richard

Fosdick, Samuel

Palmes, Edward (widower of Lucy Winthrop Palmes)

Palmes, Lucy Winthrop (deceased wife of Edward Palmes and daughter of John Winthrop)

Winthrop, Fitzjohn, Governor of Connecticut

Winthrop, John (deceased father of Lucy Winthrop Palmes)

Vessels

Liveen (ship)

Description

Issue relating to the Liveen and dispute regarding the estate of John Winthrop

Disposition

Appeals regarding both judgments are dismissed.

Notes

Related to other Privy Council appeals:

    Palmes and Hallam v [Winthrop] – Report No. 01_1699_01 (APC, v.2 [733] p.328)

    Hallam v Winthrop – Report No. 01_1699_02 (APC, v.2 [734] p.328)

The appeals of Palmes and Hallam are related, arising predominately from a dispute about the will of John Liveen, stepfather of John and Nicholas Hallam. Palmes and Hallam v [Winthrop] amounts to requests by Palmes and Hallam to require Connecticut to allow an appeal in its courts in a matter regarding the seizure of the ship Liveen, with further right to appeal to the King in Council if desired.

Hallam v Winthrop concerns the Hallam brothers’ attempt to obtain the estate of John Liveen. This case continues Palmes’s controversy regarding the Liveen and adds an appeal from a dispute related to his rights to a part of the estate of the late John Winthrop through Palmes’s late wife Lucy, daughter of John Winthrop.

These appeals are noted particularly for the comment of the crown law officers that appeals lay to the King in Council as a right inherent in the crown.


DOCUMENTATION

Printed Cases

Not found

Privy Council Documents in PC 1 at The National Archives at Kew

TNA Document Petition of Edward Palmes that his appeals be admitted – 16 Dec. 1703 – PC 1/46/5 view_Document
Notes about
Document
Referenced in APC, v.6 [110] p.24

view_APC

TNA Document Depositions re the Palmes appeal – 14 June 1705 – PC 1/46/7 view_Document
Notes about
Document
Referenced in APC, v.6 [133] p.37–38

view_APC

TNA Document Petition for hearing – 10 Jan. 1706 – PC 1/46/8 view_Document
Notes about
Document
Referenced in APC, v.6 [140] p.40

view_APC

TNA Document Committee report – 9 April 1706 (8 April in vol. 2 of APC) – PC 1/46/8 view_Document
Notes about
Document
Referenced in APC, v.6 [140] p.40

view_APC