Appeals to the Privy Council
Report No. 11_1736_00

MacSparran v Hassard

Rhode Island 

 

Case Name Short

MacSparran v Hassard

 
Case Name Long

James MacSparran v Robert Hassard

 
 

Acts of the Privy Council, Colonial Series

view_APC

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.518 – 24 November 1736 – entry 1

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.5 (1 October 1736 – 4 September 1738) p.24–25: PC 2/94/24–25

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.518 – 26 January 1737 – entry 2

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.5 (1 October 1736 – 4 September 1738) p.91, 95–96: PC 2/94/91, 95–96

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.518 – 21 February 1737 – entry 3

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.5 (1 October 1736 – 4 September 1738) p.128: PC 2/94/128

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.519–529 – 28 February 1738 – entry 4

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.5 (1 October 1736 – 4 September 1738) p.433–445: PC 2/94/433–445

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.529 – 8 March 1736 recte 1738 – entry 5

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.5 (1 October 1736 – 4 September 1738) p.476: PC 2/94/476

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.529 – 10 July 1740 – entry 6

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.7 (1 April 1740 – 7 August 1741) p.160: PC 2/96/160

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.530 – 28 April 1741 – entry 7

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.7 (1 April 1740 – 7 August 1741) p.463: PC 2/96/463

view  

APC Citation 

v.3 [390] p.530 – 7 May 1752 – entry 8

 
PC Register Citation 

George II v.13 (1 May 1750 – 30 March 1752) p.525, 536: PC 2/102/525, 536

view  

PC Register Citation 

George II v.14 (1 April 1752 – 31 December 1753) p.46, 51–54, 70: PC 2/103/46, 51–54, 70

view  

Colonial Courts

Inferior Court of Common Pleas – 6 January 1735

Superior Court of Judicature – 30 March 1736

Superior Court – 2 April 1739

Participants

Bishop of London

Brenton, Jahleel, esquire

Bull, Ivich

Bundy, James

Cheesbrough, David, gentleman, of Newport

Church, Benjamin, gentleman, of Newport

Coggeshall, Peter, gentleman, of Newport

Congdon, William

Gardner, Henry the Elder

Gardner, Ephriam, esquire

Hassard (Hazard), Robert, gentleman (tenant of Joseph Torrey)

Holme, James of South Kingstown

MacSparran, James, incumbent minister of St. Paul’s in the Pettiquamscot (Pettiquamscut, Petequamscut) Purchase and in King’s County

Mumford, George

Mumford, William, gentleman, of South Kingstown

Nyles, Rev. Samuel, minister

Potter, Thomas (tenant of James MacSparran)

Sandford, Thomas, merchant, of London

Smith, John, surveyor

Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts

Torrey, Joseph, minister

Townshend, Nathaniel, jun., gentleman, of Newport

Wilber (Wilbor), Samuel (partner in the Pettiquamscot Purchase, also spelled Pettiquamscut, Petequamscut )

Description

Land (“writ of ejectment,” according to the APC; “Action of Trespass and Ejectment,” according to the Privy Council register)

Disposition

Affirmed

Notes

Related to other Privy Council appeals:

    MacSparran v Mumford – Report No. 11_1725_00 (APC, v.3 [85] p.118)

    Torrey v Mumford – Report No. 11_1733_00 (APC, v.3 [293] p.402)

All of these Privy Council appeals concern a dispute about glebe land and have overlapping parties. There is an extensive discussion of this dispute in Bilder, Salamanders and Sons of God, ch. 6.

Multiple spellings are given for the surname of the Presbyterian minister – Miles in Torrey v Mumford; Nyles in MacSparran v Hassard; Myles in Chalmers, Opinions of Eminent Lawyers, 1:9.

A related colonial case, Torrey v Gardner, was heard in the Inferior Court on 24 June 1735 and in the Superior Court on 2 September 1735, but does not seem to have been appealed.

On the original action involved here, see Additional Research.

References in Smith, Appeals to the Privy Council from the American Plantations

Table of Cases (McSparran v Hazzard)

Additional Sources

The entire dispute produced something of a pamphlet war: A brief representation of the case depending between the Rev. Dr. Mc’Sparran, plaintiff, and the Rev. Mr. Torrey, defendant, relating to the ministry land at Narraganset [Torrey, Brief Representation]; A brief representation of the case depending between the Rev. Dr. Mc’Sparran, plaintiff, and the Rev. Mr. Torrey, defendant, relating to the ministerial land in Narraganset in a letter from a gentleman at Newport to his friend in Boston [A.B., Brief Representation]; An answer to a printed letter said to be wrote from a gentleman in Newport to his friend in Boston Aug. 27; pretending to find fault with a brief representation of the case between Dr. McSparran plaintiff and Mr. Torrey defendant, relating to the ministry land in South Kingstown, Narragansett, which was dated July 1739 [Prince, Brief Representation].

See the detailed index in Manross, Fulham Papers. He summarizes enlightening correspondence and documentation about this case, which is reproduced on Reel 5 of Lambeth Palace Library, Fulham Papers. Of special note is “Dr. MacSparran’s narrative of the lawsuit concerning the glebe land at Narragansett in New England” in manuscript.


DOCUMENTATION

Printed Cases

Appellant’s case

Case of the appellant (MacSparran)

Counsel

[Signed] W. Murray

 
Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36217 f. 1–2

view

Library

Law Library of Congress: Sir George Lee collection (Minor underlining on first page)

view

Respondent’s case

Case of the respondent (Hassard)

Counsel

[Signed] D. Ryder; A. Hume-Campbell

 
Library

British Library: (Hardwicke Papers) Additional Manuscripts 36217 f.3–6 (Includes manuscript notes)

view

Library

Law Library of Congress: Sir George Lee collection (Includes manuscript notes)

view

Privy Council Documents in PC 1 at The National Archives at Kew

Not found